Demolition v Refurbishment in Social Housing – What’s the Carbon Cost?

Simon Guy • 23 January 2023

With the growing focus on circular economy and embodied carbon, the social housing sector is increasingly recognising that site redevelopment decisions are extremely important for sustainability, especially for reducing carbon. Reclamation of building materials can significantly reduce the amount of embodied carbon in the new projects that utilise them. But how do you know the carbon cost of demolition, and the relative cost when compared to refurbishment?


Social housing providers are being driven towards enhanced measurement and reporting of circularity and carbon by a number of factors. Firstly, there has been policy development in several UK regions that calls for the measurement of reclamation and recovery potential and embodied carbon during projects. In London for instance, Circular Economy Statements must now be submitted for any referable projects (i.e. projects of a certain scale that must be approved by the Mayor’s office), requiring that a pre-demolition audit is undertaken.


These must be submitted alongside Whole Life Carbon Assessments, which may include the embodied carbon avoided through the reuse and recycling of demolition arisings. Moreover, there is a requirement for a pre-redevelopment audit whereby justification for demolition of buildings is required. In Wales, the draft Welsh Housing Quality Standard would require that “Landlords should… compare embodied and operational carbon in the proposal for retrofitting homes, as opposed to a proposal for demolishing and redeveloping homes”.


Many organisations, including social housing providers, have also now set targets relating to carbon, net zero and circular economy as part of their ESG efforts, often covering scope 3 emissions which includes the emissions through the value chain (and therefore associated with construction material usage, reclamation, waste, and disposal). Assessment and reporting standards are increasingly used by social housing providers to monitor performance, such as the Housing Quality Mark (HQM) at the level of individual projects and assets, or SHIFT and the Sustainability Reporting Standard for Social Housing (SRS) at the organisation level.


In general, therefore, the sector is moving towards increased reporting and transparency, requiring better and better tools for capturing, analysing, interpreting, and presenting data. However this is where a greater need arises to calculate a building's composition,  and its reclamation and recycling potential.


Without this information, a social housing provider’s performance (or potential performance) on carbon emissions and circular use of materials cannot be fully quantified, and ambitious targets cannot be set and monitored.


Reusefully, together with partners Sustenic, Salvo and Cambridge Sustainable Design, are working on an Innovate UK project entitled ‘PreaDeM – the Pre-Demolition Environmental Assessment and Decision Making Platform’. This project is funded by Innovate UK under the NICER programme, which aims to encourage innovation in circular economy thinking.


The PreaDeM team are currently developing a specification for a tool (or more likely a toolkit) which will provide a rapid assessment of the reuse potential in a dwelling, and the carbon impact of refurbishment as opposed to demolition.


The focus is on developing something that is easy-to-use, and begins with a desk-based study to make use of publicly available data, such as data from Ordnance Survey or Google Streetview for example. it also needs to make best use of information that is built in on typical building and social housing typologies. 


The project is looking to set out the specific data requirements and data capture methodologies to standardise the various stages (from desk study to site visit to analysis and reporting), and investigating the potential for innovative tools and technologies to streamline data capture, analysis and reporting. We are also looking at how a tool could be used by different ‘user groups’ such as the assessors who carry out pre-demolition audits on behalf of social housing providers. There could also be potential for housing providers themselves to use the tool for a quick circular economy and embodied carbon assessment of their assets.


The intention with this is to obtain a rapid and high-level insight, which in some cases might provide enough information to avoid a potentially time consuming and costly site visit and audit.



Data collection templates are currently being trialled on a number of ‘live’ projects of social housing projects up and down the UK. A basic data analysis protocol has been developed, which involves a standard method of aggregating data from the data collection template, carrying out analytics (including reclamation and recycling potential evaluation and embodied carbon analysis), and presenting the findings in an easy-to-interpret reporting format in the form of tables and graphs that can be inserted into a client report.


If you would like to find out more about the PreaDeM project, or are a social housing provider who would be interested in trialling the tool, please get in touch via the Contact form above.


by Simon Guy 13 May 2026
A new collaborative project funded under the York and North Yorkshire Combined Authority’s Carbon Negative Challenge Fund aims to drive reuse and materials sharing for the region by creating and promoting industrial symbiosis.
by Theo Simondetti 20 April 2026
We are in the middle of a quiet revolution in how the design and construction industries think about materials. For decades, the story of a building or an office fit-out followed a familiar arc: specify new, install, and when the lease runs out or the brand refresh arrives, strip it all out and dispose of it. That model is no longer tenable — environmentally, economically, or ethically. Reusefully's Theo Simondetti explains how creative reuse is becoming a powerful tool available to designers.
by Simon Guy 16 April 2026
The Scottish Government launched its Circular Economy Strategy towards the end of last month, with the built environment identified as one of five areas of priority.
by Simon Guy 12 February 2026
How can planning policy influence and support the development of the circular economy in construction and what actions can municipalities take to support circularity and reuse? At the end of January, Reusefully hosted a webinar on this topic with contributions from more than 100 attendees who joined from across the UK, Denmark and beyond.
by Gillian Hobbs 21 November 2025
As COP30 closes today in Brazil, most headlines have centred on forests and energy. But there’s another critical question we must ask "where will people live in a climate-safe future? Gilli Hobbs of Reusefully and Ana Quintas of Sustenuto reflect on affordable housing, sustainability and quality. Affordable housing isn’t only a social priority, it’s a climate imperative. Sustainable development can only succeed if construction, housing, and social impact move forward together. Around 11 years ago, whilst at BRE, we were invited to a pan government and industry workshop to discuss affordable housing and priorities to improve sustainability and quality in the next (highly ambitious) phases of the Minha Casa Minha Vida programme. There had already been around 3 million homes built over 7 years. An impressive feat that resulted in millions of Brazilians having formal housing for the first time. However, there were issues arising from these developments that needed to be resolved prior to the next wave of developments. In 2015, we launched a programme with Caixa Econômica Federal and UNDP to strengthen sustainability in Brazil’s social housing sector - Advancing the Sustainability of Social Housing Developments in Brazil. The goal was to raise environmental performance and building quality in Brazil’s Minha Casa Minha Vida programme, which has provided millions of homes for low-income families. These earlier housing developments offer important lessons, while future programmes present opportunities to embed higher sustainability standards from the start. To support this evolution, our team and partners developed a set of tools and methodologies: Sustainability Standard for Social Housing : A framework to support governance, tools, training, and guidance to programme managers and operators. Balanced Scorecard : A holistic evaluation approach covering infrastructure, services, and the social, economic, and environmental sustainability of communities. Post-Occupancy Evaluation : A robust methodology adapted to the Brazilian context, enabling consistent data collection on housing performance and resident experience. Impact Assessment : Although data gaps limited a full evaluation, we provided strategic guidance to strengthen future assessments. Dissemination Phase : Workshops with industry, associations, and residents, supported by CAIXA, UNDP, and the Ministry of Cities, ensured wide engagement and knowledge sharing. This work marked the beginning of a long-term journey: embedding sustainability not just in buildings, but in governance, urban planning, and community development. Watch this short video on how Brazil approached sustainable housing challenges a decade ago. Why this matters today Buildings account for nearly 40% of global energy-related emissions. Every affordable home built without sustainability locks in decades of inefficiency, higher costs, and increased climate risk for families who can least afford it. As COP30 ends, the real work begins. Climate justice isn’t only about forests and energy transitions . It’s also about homes—where people live, raise families, and build their futures. Sustainable development only succeeds when housing, construction, climate resilience, and social impact move hand in hand. COP30 reminds us of a simple truth: climate justice starts at home. What did we learn? Our project was quite intense, involving many stakeholders from across Brazil. The level of collaboration and determination to provide more sustainable and resilient homes for the poorest segment of society was very impressive – for which it won an award as you can see below.
by Simon Guy 13 November 2025
45 Waterloo Street is a 95,500 sq ft office building acquired by RoundShield and CEG Group earlier this year which is currently undergoing refurbishment by the new owners. This includes a full internal refurbishment, refreshed external elevations, a new external roof terrace and removal of the large, glazed atrium to the rear of the building. The building is situated in Glasgow’s busy financial services district.
More posts